Brooke McKinney, educator, instructional designer, researcher, and speaker, featured on The Engaging Teacher About page. Portrait with botanical Dusty Bloom design and the message “Helping Educators, Leaders, and Organizations Make Judgment Visible.”
Brooke McKinney: TEDx Speaker • Instructional Designer • AI Learning Architect

Long before I was a teacher, I was a barista.

For fourteen years, I worked in coffee shops, eventually serving as a trainer who taught everyone from first-day hires to coffee executives.

At first, I thought expertise was easy to recognize.

Surely the best employees would be the ones who memorized the most information.

The ones who knew the origins of every coffee.

The ones who mastered every recipe.

The ones who could make every drink on the menu.

But over time, I noticed something else.

The people who stood out weren’t always the fastest learners.

They were the ones who noticed things.

They recognized a frustrated customer before anyone else.

They adapted when something went wrong.

They remained calm under pressure.

They knew when to follow a process—and when to depart from it.

They exercised judgment.

And the more I paid attention, the more fascinated I became by a question:

Why are some forms of capability easy to measure while others are easy to miss?

Years later, I found myself asking the same question in classrooms.

Students could produce impressive work without understanding.

Others demonstrated remarkable insight that never appeared on traditional assessments.

As a teacher, department chair, instructional designer, and researcher, I kept returning to the same realization:

The artifact was never the capability.

It was evidence of capability.

That realization became the foundation for everything I create today—from my work on engagement, assessment, and instructional design to my research on learning, judgment, and artificial intelligence.

Because when artifacts stop proving thinking, we need better ways to make human capability visible.

My career has taken me through classrooms, leadership roles, curriculum design, faculty development, and educational technology.

As an AP Language and Composition teacher and English Department Chair, I became fascinated by a challenge that still drives me today:

Why do some learning experiences produce genuine growth while others produce only compliance?

Over time, I noticed that many of our educational systems were optimized for collecting artifacts rather than revealing thinking.

Students learned how to complete assignments.

Organizations learned how to collect evidence.

Yet the qualities we valued most—judgment, reasoning, curiosity, trust, adaptability, and discernment—often remained invisible.

AI didn’t create this problem.

It exposed it.

Artifacts are useful.

But artifacts are not capability.

When evidence becomes easier to generate, educators and leaders must become better at identifying what truly matters.

Human judgment is observable.

It appears in decisions, reasoning, reflection, revisions, tradeoffs, and explanations.

The challenge is designing environments where those traces become visible.

People do their best thinking when they feel safe enough to wonder, challenge assumptions, and take intellectual risks.

Learning is not merely cognitive.

It is human.

My work currently centers around several connected frameworks:

A framework for identifying where judgment becomes visible within learning experiences.

A model for understanding why traditional artifacts are becoming less reliable indicators of capability in an AI-enabled world.

The AI-Era Assessment Visibility Matrix™

A practical framework for evaluating where student judgment is visible within assessments and learning experiences.

A model describing the conditions that make meaningful learning, thinking, and transfer possible.

A decision-making framework for selecting learning experiences, evidence, and assessments that align with intended outcomes.

I work with schools, universities, nonprofits, and organizations to design learning experiences that prioritize judgment, capability, and meaningful engagement.

Services include:

  • Keynote Speaking
  • Faculty Development
  • Leadership Development
  • AI Integration Strategy
  • Instructional Design Consulting
  • Curriculum Development
  • Workshops and Retreats

Many of these ideas emerged from a lifelong fascination with invisible forms of capability.

As an educator, researcher, designer, and autistic adult, I have spent years wondering why some strengths are easy to recognize while others remain hidden beneath expectations, assumptions, and traditional measures of success.

That curiosity continues to shape everything I create.

Because ultimately, this work is not about artificial intelligence.

It is about people.

It is about learning.

It is about creating environments where human judgment, capability, and potential become visible.

Brooke McKinney presenting on assessment, visible thinking, and artificial intelligence with the phrase “The Work Has Stopped Proving the Thinking” displayed behind her.
Still asking the same question: How do we make human capability visible?

Whether you’re exploring AI integration, redesigning assessment, developing leaders, or creating more engaging learning experiences, I’d love to connect.

brooke@theengagingteacher.com

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨